Miles Davis Live at the Plugged Nickel

[JSngry]

Somebody define "noodling* in an objective, quantifiable way. Please.

[Steve Reynolds]

I’ve brought many friends to live shows. Mostly very abstract avant-garde music. Most like or even loved it. All have different backgrounds in listening. One is a huge Dead listener (like me). Others are into Tool, popular music or are into straight jazz, modern punk or post punk. None had ever heard any of the music I go see live as most of it is beneath the underground and seemingly incomprehensible. Much more “out” than the great mid 60’s Miles quintet. 

key is that they go in with little pre-conceived ideas about what it or or try to understand it. With an open mind most anyone will find something to like with genius master musicians improvising in a small intimate room. 

Mat Maneri, Hamid Drake, Gerry Hemingway, David Torn, Ches Smith, Nate Wooley, Brandon Lopez, Nels Cline, Randy Peterson, Darius Jones, Mary Halvorson, Tomeka Reid, Michael Foster, Tyshawn Sorey, Chuck Roth, Tom Rainey or Tony Malaby playing in front of an unsuspecting listener?

Almost all can’t believe nobody knows these musicians after the shows. They know it’s “out” but they don’t hear it the way serious straight ahead jazz listeners hear it. A few struggled with the purely improvised stuff but most get into the actual playing. 

My wife liked it. Sometimes the screaming altissimo stuff might get her a bit nervous, but she LOVED the drummers. 

[gvopedz]

58 minutes ago, Kevin Bresnahan said:

 I worked in the high tech industry for decades with some pretty brilliant people. Over the years, I tried getting a lot of them to listen to Jazz - often by playing it in the lab on a boombox to get it heard - and a lot of them came over and said that they didn't like it because it sounded like noodling. 

Getting coworkers to enjoy jazz may require a bit more strategy.  I once had a coworker who often listened to recordings of classical music performed on a piano.  So I brought in a Bill Evans CD, and she liked the jazz that Bill Evans performed.

[Stompin at the Savoy]

I was wondering why this set has been out of print for 30 years.  I mean Miles Davis - they are reissuing him over and over all over the place!  And yet this sat for 30 years.  I was listening to it yesterday and it occurred to me that that this set is somewhat challenging for a novice jazz listener.  Most of the studio stuff is fairly short tunes with theme statement, solos, theme statement, coda.  But this set is sort of for the advanced class.  Sometimes the melody doesn't appear till way into the tune and in a mutated form, the solos are abstract and experimental - without some background it could be hard to grok.  I was very impressed with this when I got it back in the nineties but I have listened to it less than other miles.   I think everybody should hear it at some point but it maybe is not the best set to play to a jazz newbie.

1 hour ago, Steve Reynolds said:

I’ve brought many friends to live shows. Mostly very abstract avant-garde music. Most like or even loved it. All have different backgrounds in listening. One is a huge Dead listener (like me). Others are into Tool, popular music or are into straight jazz, modern punk or post punk. None had ever heard any of the music I go see live as most of it is beneath the underground and seemingly incomprehensible. Much more “out” than the great mid 60’s Miles quintet. 

key is that they go in with little pre-conceived ideas about what it or or try to understand it. With an open mind most anyone will find something to like with genius master musicians improvising in a small intimate room. 

Mat Maneri, Hamid Drake, Gerry Hemingway, David Torn, Ches Smith, Nate Wooley, Brandon Lopez, Nels Cline, Randy Peterson, Darius Jones, Mary Halvorson, Tomeka Reid, Michael Foster, Tyshawn Sorey, Chuck Roth, Tom Rainey or Tony Malaby playing in front of an unsuspecting listener?

Almost all can’t believe nobody knows these musicians after the shows. They know it’s “out” but they don’t hear it the way serious straight ahead jazz listeners hear it. A few struggled with the purely improvised stuff but most get into the actual playing. 

My wife liked it. Sometimes the screaming altissimo stuff might get her a bit nervous, but she LOVED the drummers. 

Yes, I have had better luck bringing newbies to a live jazz performance than playing a record for them.  You are there, watching them play, picking up cues from the audience - it's exciting.

[Kevin Bresnahan]

1 hour ago, gvopedz said:

Getting coworkers to enjoy jazz may require a bit more strategy.  I once had a coworker who often listened to recordings of classical music performed on a piano.  So I brought in a Bill Evans CD, and she liked the jazz that Bill Evans performed.

I got some of them really digging Herbie's "Head Hunters". I could crank that and they would all seem to dig it.

For some reason, straight ahead stuff just didn't work for most of them.

My wife enjoys Jazz pianists. She's less enthused with reeds & trumpet players.

[jazzbo]

Well I would not myself say that this set has been completely invisible for thirty years. Japan reissued their version of it on gold cd after the US set went out of print, and another company released more than half of it as an LP set; individual and 2 cd versions have been reissued separately and as part of the "Complete Columbia Album" box set. Much of the music has been bouncing around.

I too would not recommend this to a jazz novice. . . but I also don't think it's that inaccessible to someone who is on a jazz journey.

[Kevin Bresnahan]

15 hours ago, bertrand said:

Why are you always picking fights with me? I'm not making this up.

I'm done with this Board. Bye everyone.

@bertrand I don't think we're picking fights. I know we're definitely not trying to piss you off.  

I have to say... I don't recall the complete Plugged Nickel set having an issue with one of the CDs either and a deep-dive Google search comes up blank. I even searched the Internet wayback machine. I would think that if this happened as you are recalling, someone, somewhere should have either a set with a defective disc or a set with the corrected CD-R disc but I am having no luck finding any for sale.

Does anyone here have a set with a CD-R or a defective disc?

I would not be happy if a box set with a defective disc was replaced with a CD-R. Long term CD-R reliability is all over the place, with some people losing large batches and others seeing no degradation. It may even be coming down to how they were burned at this point and not the blank media used.