Ellingtonian level mastery, i don't hear that. I hear solid musicality, eclecticism, use of what's in the air in the culture generally and more immediately in his associates, etc. I just don't hear genius, or anything like it.
Bought an LP of this (which I'd never seen before) the other day when I went to Music Millennium to get the new Sonny. Short (8 tunes, under 30 min) and kind of a 'small' work in other ways too, but quite enjoyable. Don't know that I've ever heard Cohn on baritone before. Apparently was dbl'e up on CD with the even more oddball We Dig Cole featuring Charlie Shavers, Sam 'the man' Taylor and Urbie green. What say you?
Don't mean to be disrespectful, to U or Prince, but I just really do NOT hear this...wish I did, but no. Maybe I should start a poll, I have the sense that this is a bit of a dividing line...
"'I do not scream' said Gato, 'for the same reasons Pharaoh Sanders screams'". Some liner note verbiage that stuck in my head. He certainly had his own voice. Last Tango (expanded), Latin America (expanded), and the duets with Dollar Brand are my go-to selections. And the first side of Yesterdays on Flying Dutchman with "Yesterdays" and "A John Coltrane Blues" (even if it sounds more like King Curtis goes latin).
I think 'the greatest singer of postwar popular music' is a false construct ("in the history of" is just redundant), but if you had to choose one she'd be as good a candidate as any...BUT there is certainly no consensus on such matters that I've noticed, now more/less than ever. It's not as obnoxious and infuriating as the guy who said in the NYR that 'of course Cole Porter is a wittier songwriter than Chuck Berry', but it's not a particularly insightful or enlightening statement. Did he go on to do any close analysis of Aretha's actual practises as a singer, or does he just stay in the mist of offhand generality?
I've found to be true of Tommy Flanagan's sideman dates too...I'm thinking there was more going on there than I'm hearing, although what I'm hearing is fine...