Ah, Leeway...you got to Chuck Berry first! Damn, I was going to post that!
Anyway, let me say that if Chuck ain't considered a "great" songwriter...I'll eat my guitar! Well...maybe not...but damn he wrote some unforgettable tunes.
I'll also throw in Curtis Mayfield....
As far as Jim's post regarding "is it a great SONG?"....I haven't a clue, I don't have the music education background to be considered a real "critic". I think he's 100% correct that it's a totally subjective discussion.
Here's the way I look at it...the only opinion that really matters is your own...if you get moved by the Sex Pistols singing "No Feelings"...SO BE IT!!! Then, it's a great fucking song...to the only critic that matters. It's fun to see people's choices in these types of discussions...gives you a little insight into their head, sometimes share a common experience that a certain song or performer has inspired in you. But in the end, that magical song could have been "Wango Tango" by Ted Nugent! And we all know what a GENIUS he was!!
But...if someone forced me at gunpoint to tell them what I thought made a great song...GREAT...it would probably come out something like..."It's memorable, sounds timeless and inspired others". Not exactly a scientific approach (because the same criteria could be used to describe commercial jingles) but I'm stickin' to it.