Yeah, I put the ratings in and they're lowered. I don't know, generally I only send them the stuff I think is really good and could use some cross-genre attention, since they mostly cover rock & electronic music.
I've done one 5 and one 4.5 in two years, most are in the three or four range. If anything's below three, I just don't bother with it at least for this pub. For NYCJR or even my own blog, I've definitely noted some 2s - or would, if a rating system was in use.
Would be curious if any o-board contributors to places like Down Beat have anything to add, since that pub. relied so heavily on ratings. If it were up to me the star/dot system would be kaput.