I like RVG editions apparently more than most people. To me on my system they appear to be more "live" -- to sound more like a live performance, where I have a front of stage table, than a recorded studio performance, and I like that. Also the pre-tape RVG reissues sound fantastic to me, better than anything else I've heard of those sessions.
There's definitely a place for these SACDs and XRCDs for those who have demanding stereo systems and demanding ears and who want the most HIFI sound of these classic sessions. I bought two of the XRCDs and think they're very well done. I don't think I'll buy any more of the first 25. I have all the titles in at least one other version and I just feel that it's time to stop rebuying these sessions over and over. I'd be a lot more tempted if the choices were less "safe." I'd love to see the "hot jazz" on Blue Note reissued in this series or the early modern jazz of Monk and Bud and others on the label. And just for the variety and to hear what these would sound like in this sort of mastering I'd love to see larger ensemble titles such as Joy Ride, Delightful Lee, Lift Every Voice appear in this series. I'd surrender to temptation then most likely. But mainly we have quintet and quartet dates and a safe sameness to the selections.
Welcome Hannibal!