The RCA set has a 40 page booklet with extensive notes by Loren Schoenberg and some nice photos. The Definitives I've seen have "generic notes". I can't respond to your general aversion to alternates. They probably "copped" the RCA mastering and twiddled with it a bit. Good luck.
Help me with this - does the estate have any rights regarding the reissue of a legitimate album?
I wonder if the undoctored tapes (this date is a studio recording with dubbed applause) can't be found?
IIRC, they found and "rehabilitated" the real "live" tapes and were planning an issue of those.
Very fine playing (on modern piano) available inexpensively:
Walter Klien on 2 Vox doubles. They have also recently reissued a 3 disc set of variations and other pieces.
The Farmer estate made really unreasonable demands and the project was shelved. I have heard recently they relented a bit and the issue might come out.
Ah, I see - do you think those people chose Blue Note or was it EMI who did the deciding?
MG
No clue.
Guy
In (at least) the majority of those cases, the "artist" chose the "label".
It is really disheartening to see so many recent vinyl pressings. If they are "what they claim" they are yet another use of precious "primary sources". Bad for culture, good for collectors.
Don't have a bunch of old JazzTimes to search but ask you to check Litweiler's notes for "Slice of the Top" and quote the passages showing him " penniless and homeless in Philadelphia".