Since I'm feeling contentious tonight, I essentially agree with Kevin & Dan.
I think I said this a while back on some other thread that one of the active participants in this one had a major role in - opinions are like ********, everybody has one(sorry for the cliche).
While (I guess) some opinions are more valid than others, in the end (after almost 50 years of listening) it still boils down to what makes your day as an individual listener.
BTW, I like Heavy Hitters too.
Disclaimer - I've never met Eric Alexander or heard him in person. It's just that several of his CDs give me listening pleasure. Very subjective, but so what.