Who cares what the record sounds like with that great cover art!
It ain't THAT bad anyhow. Certianly not on the level of his Contemporary LP's but still listenable enough, no matter what Down Beat and Gioia said. Looking at the Down Beat review (2 stars) I've got a hunch that beyond recording quality issues they picked this record as one of those where they failed all the participants summarily for being "derivative" (one of their favorite derogatory terms of those years, it seems ), not creating something substantially new, etc. - i.e. their pet peeve they seem to have nourished at that time, proving you can downgrade anything if you feel like it.
Just my 2c - and yes, at times I do take the liberty of disagreeing with certain review "authorities"
Sure, it's not the best Counce album, but I'm glad I have it and think any fan would be.
My copy says "Boplicity" AND "Dootone" and I just chose the first one.
Don't overlook that Harold Land album, Tom!