Sorry, I was just venting.
A similar thing happened with my Air recording - the reviewer thought he was getting a different group and was pissed. The review has now been removed.
I buy lots of stuff on Amazon (never check the cd reviews) and rely on reviews for other stuff like faucets, appliances, etc. This suggests to me negative reviews do matter.
The "ax to grind" thing was related to the attack on Fred Atwood, not the recording (or me).
I wasn't fishing for positive reviews, just letting off steam. This was probably a result of taking Chantix.