I really enjoy his recordings, but in the last twenty years he has not been as creative and consistent as he was in the first ten years of his career. IMHO, post Blood & Chocolate/King of America, he has had four perfect recordings: Brutal Youth (which many people would debate, but I love), Painted from Memory, The Delivery Man, and The River in Reverse. To my ears, When I Was Cruel never really clicked. I think it worked for some fans because it was his first "rock" recording in quite sometime, so they were so happy that he was playing rock again that there expectations for the songs was very lower then my own.
I would endorse The River in Reverse to anyone. It works as a Elvis CD and as a Toussaint CD. Elvis really does a great job reinterpreting some of the songs that were made famous by Lee Dorsey, which I never thought I would be able to say.