I think Sandler's huge fund of barely-disguised hostility would have made him good for the role, but his hyper-recognizability would have made him terrible. So I'm glad he wasn't used.
this "barely-disguised hostility" (i refer to it as rage) you mention is what made Sandler perfect for Anderson's Punch Drunk Love. one of my absolute favorite movies. and his 'hyper-recognizability' didn't hurt the film at all in my opinion. the flip side to Sandler's rage is his seeming 'hyper-sensitivity.' seems to me Anderson wrote the role w/ this exact combination in mind and maybe w/ Sandler in mind because that's already his M.O. for anyone paying attention. maybe the character was even inspired by Sandler himself. i'll write Anderson a letter...
but since i haven't seen IB, i can't speak to Sandler in it (or not).
Quite. My impression was that Anderson did indeed fashion the role with Sandler in mind; it certainly wouldn't surprise me at least. Something about Punch Drunk Love didn't work for me, though...it was only a half-successful movie as far as I'm concerned. On the other hand, Sandler was fine in Funny People (not his fault the film was too long.) I feel strongly that using him as the "bear Jew" in IB would have been stunt casting of the worst sort, and a distraction. As Mike Myers WAS a distraction, though a more minor one.