Bringing the conversation back to Balliett - I have always thought he was a really bright guy with "really" flawed musical insight. Not bad, not good, just very interesting prose.
Younger folks might find this difficult to understand but he was a beacon for us in the '50s and '60s, whether you agreed or not.
Thank you Mr. Balliett.
JHW always pissed me off and think his reputation outruns his "insight".