I started listening to jazz in the early 1980s. Received a fantastic education on the classics from a college music professor. As for then current releases, relied on a great college record store staff. They directed me all over the place without regard to "bucket" i.e. Chick Corea and Muhal Richard Abrams simply both played keyboards.
As for the stuff we are talking about, I read heard all about Wynton Marsalis and also knew of the current guys in the Blakey band. I saw an iteration circa 1984 or so with Blanchard/Harrison . Over the next few years, I generally came to the belief this music was stilted and moved toward more adventurous folks. Nevertheless, a bunch of neo-bop/young lion lps/CDs ended up in my collection.
Listening to some of them over the past few months, a few opinions:
Ralph Peterson - Blue Note LPs - very solid, exciting, both he and his soloists
Geri Allen - same
Kenny Kirkland - that album on GRP, while not fully a lost classic, is very nice as is most of his playing elsewhere
Brandford Marsalis - there is a ton of it out there, both as a leader and sideman, holds my attention, although hard to cite a favorite or classic
Wynton Marsalis - what is that dude up to? generally very boring, Black Codes and the Blues Alley date are exceptions. Who buys this stuff?
Terence Blanchard - solo - generally good stuff, some good records that moved away from the neo-bop thing, more of his own sound
Harper Brothers - actually saw them live, very spirited, but similar reaction to DMP on a CD
Stephen Scott - a favorite back then and I stiff enjoy those Verve CDs
Mulgrew Miller - very much enjoy the Landmark/Novus band LPs
Kenny Garrett - hit or miss, own more than I enjoy
Bennie Wallace - did not care for at the time, glad I kept them, like 'em now
Chico Freeman - particularly his Musician/Contemporary LPs, loved them then, love them now
Marcus Printup - really dug the Blue Note LPs, still enjoy today
Joshua Redman - got zero traction with him
Vincent Herring - liked the Landmark CD with Nat Adderley, but hard to engage beyond that
Roy Hargrove - from the moment he jumped off a Bobby Watson LP, always loved his sound/style
Leaving many folks out, but definitely some winners above.